Skip to content

Botswana vs Sierra Leone statistics compared

Updated on by Georank team

Botswana has a population of 2.52M (ranked 142/197), compared with 8.64M in Sierra Leone (ranked 102/197). Botswana's land area is 218,816 sq mi versus 27,869 sq mi for Sierra Leone (ranked 47th vs. 116th).

By GDP, Botswana ranks 133/197 ($19.4B) and Sierra Leone ranks 160/197 ($6.97B). By GDP per capita, Botswana ranks 97/197 ($7,696), while Sierra Leone ranks 186/197 ($807).

Main facts and rankings

Botswana Sierra Leone
Population
2603835
8998687
Population rank 142/197 102/197
GDP
$19.4B
2024
$6.97B
2024
GDP rank 133/197 160/197
GDP per capita
$7,696
2024
$807
2024
GDP per capita rank 97/197 186/197
GDP per capita, PPP
$20,538
2024
$3,522
2024
Government debt
$6.36B
2024
$3B
2024
Debt-to-GDP ratio
50.3%
2026
44.6%
2026
Government debt per person
$2,523
2024
$347
2024
Government debt per person rank 110/185 173/185
Average annual personal income after taxes
$4,596
2026
$3,438
2026
Land area
218,816 sq mi
2026
27,869 sq mi
2026
Population density
11.5 ppl/mi²
2024
310 ppl/mi²
2024
Fertility rate
2.73
2023
3.79
2023
Median age
24.2 years
2024
20.5 years
2024
Life expectancy
69.6 years
2026
62.3 years
2026

Botswana and Sierra Leone: Comparison Charts

Botswana and Sierra Leone economies compared

GDP
Botswana

Sierra Leone
Year GDP
Botswana Sierra Leone
1960 $30,411,414 $322,009,962
1961 $32,902,613 $327,834,191
1962 $35,644,957 $342,721,416
1963 $38,091,843 $348,547,279
1964 $41,616,348 $371,847,461
1965 $45,788,696 $359,379,856
1966 $51,465,655 $375,479,850
1967 $58,642,354 $348,795,303
1968 $66,248,441 $329,859,732
1969 $77,361,547 $408,690,163
1970 $96,243,234 $434,410,974
1971 $127,448,614 $419,549,305
1972 $164,460,915 $465,381,340
1973 $244,124,164 $575,230,724
1974 $306,044,208 $648,590,643
1975 $355,168,572 $679,336,344
1976 $372,025,093 $594,895,942
1977 $451,624,780 $691,777,584
1978 $590,407,374 $960,728,339
1979 $819,870,259 $1,109,374,911
1980 $1,060,889,704 $1,100,685,845
1981 $1,073,812,830 $1,114,830,472
1982 $1,014,945,696 $1,295,361,886
1983 $1,172,230,397 $995,104,305
1984 $1,240,822,167 $1,087,471,862
1985 $1,114,783,343 $856,890,459
1986 $1,392,602,164 $490,181,457
1987 $1,965,226,890 $660,106,336
1988 $2,644,554,159 $1,055,083,933
1989 $3,083,822,112 $932,974,420
1990 $3,790,636,324 $649,644,098
1991 $3,942,876,703 $779,981,987
1992 $4,146,464,587 $679,940,814
1993 $4,160,129,175 $768,867,883
1994 $4,259,259,604 $911,853,802
1995 $4,730,599,122 $870,740,292
1996 $4,847,757,218 $941,709,423
1997 $5,020,265,627 $850,232,760
1998 $4,790,481,509 $672,368,187
1999 $5,484,263,347 $669,386,624
2000 $5,788,329,609 $635,866,404
2001 $5,489,608,300 $1,681,473,894
2002 $5,438,863,983 $1,933,863,911
2003 $7,511,582,173 $2,142,618,046
2004 $8,957,467,707 $2,237,350,687
2005 $9,918,907,108 $2,545,275,313
2006 $9,919,158,482 $3,263,697,467
2007 $10,567,270,656 $3,632,957,611
2008 $10,730,829,116 $4,157,895,298
2009 $10,118,459,242 $3,953,403,098
2010 $12,637,273,429 $4,262,805,967
2011 $15,110,643,612 $4,861,632,885
2012 $13,907,464,500 $6,141,666,509
2013 $14,271,738,933 $7,502,762,863
2014 $15,470,088,501 $7,686,138,791
2015 $13,530,748,845 $6,788,352,975
2016 $15,082,637,184 $6,084,297,211
2017 $16,105,155,857 $5,749,846,528
2018 $17,031,943,186 $6,390,514,689
2019 $16,725,908,149 $6,523,577,594
2020 $14,960,251,608 $6,688,307,703
2021 $18,750,182,236 $7,166,931,485
2022 $20,321,150,599 $7,121,125,278
2023 $19,411,266,967 $6,415,852,767
2024 $19,402,063,513 $6,971,127,235

Botswana and Sierra Leone economies compared

GDP per capita
Botswana

Sierra Leone
Year GDP per capita
Botswana Sierra Leone
1960 $58.9 $142
1961 $62.3 $142.3
1962 $66 $146.3
1963 $68.9 $146.3
1964 $73.5 $153.4
1965 $79.7 $145.6
1966 $89.1 $149.3
1967 $100.9 $136.1
1968 $113.4 $126.3
1969 $131.8 $153.6
1970 $163 $160.2
1971 $212.2 $151.8
1972 $264.2 $165.4
1973 $374 $200.6
1974 $446 $222.1
1975 $493 $228.4
1976 $490 $196.4
1977 $565 $224.2
1978 $695 $305
1979 $909 $346
1980 $1,132 $336
1981 $1,107 $334
1982 $1,006 $380
1983 $1,121 $285.8
1984 $1,145 $306
1985 $994 $235.5
1986 $1,200 $131.5
1987 $1,639 $172.4
1988 $2,141 $268.2
1989 $2,428 $231.3
1990 $2,903 $154.8
1991 $2,939 $183.7
1992 $3,005 $163.2
1993 $2,929 $185
1994 $2,917 $218.5
1995 $3,156 $208.4
1996 $3,156 $224.3
1997 $3,194 $199.9
1998 $2,981 $156.5
1999 $3,340 $155
2000 $3,451 $143.7
2001 $3,206 $358
2002 $3,117 $389
2003 $4,230 $414
2004 $4,957 $418
2005 $5,391 $463
2006 $5,292 $580
2007 $5,529 $632
2008 $5,503 $705
2009 $5,083 $653
2010 $6,216 $685
2011 $7,287 $761
2012 $6,596 $938
2013 $6,667 $1,117
2014 $7,122 $1,118
2015 $6,141 $965
2016 $6,749 $844
2017 $7,105 $779
2018 $7,408 $846
2019 $7,172 $844
2020 $6,323 $845
2021 $7,808 $885
2022 $8,329 $860
2023 $7,826 $758
2024 $7,696 $807

Botswana vs. Sierra Leone life expectancy calculator

Life expectancy
Botswana

Sierra Leone
Year Life expectancy, years
Botswana Sierra Leone
1950 46.2 28.9
1951 46.6 29.3
1952 47 29.7
1953 47.5 30.1
1954 48 30.5
1955 48.5 30.9
1956 49 31.3
1957 49.5 31.8
1958 50.1 32.1
1959 50.7 32.6
1960 51.2 33.1
1961 51.8 33.6
1962 52.3 34.2
1963 52.8 34.7
1964 53.4 35.3
1965 53.9 35.9
1966 54.4 36.6
1967 54.9 37.3
1968 55.4 37.8
1969 55.9 38.2
1970 56.4 38.6
1971 57.1 39.1
1972 57.7 39.5
1973 58.3 40
1974 58.9 40.4
1975 59.5 41
1976 60.2 41.4
1977 60.9 41.8
1978 61.5 42.2
1979 62 42.5
1980 62.5 42.8
1981 63 43.1
1982 63.4 43.3
1983 63.6 43.5
1984 63.7 43.6
1985 63.6 43.6
1986 63.4 43.5
1987 62.8 43.7
1988 61.7 43.8
1989 61.2 43.7
1990 60.1 43.7
1991 58.9 43.3
1992 58.2 43.5
1993 57.3 43.4
1994 56 42.8
1995 54.7 42.6
1996 54.3 43.5
1997 53.6 43.6
1998 53 42.7
1999 52.5 42
2000 52.3 44.8
2001 52.2 45.4
2002 52.4 46.2
2003 52.9 46.8
2004 53.6 47.5
2005 54.4 48.3
2006 55.1 49.5
2007 56.7 50
2008 57.7 50.7
2009 58.3 51.3
2010 59.1 51.9
2011 59.7 52.6
2012 60.4 53.2
2013 61.2 54.1
2014 62.2 54.3
2015 63.2 55.5
2016 64.3 56.9
2017 65.4 57.8
2018 66.4 59.1
2019 67.2 59.6
2020 67.6 59.7
2021 63.3 60.3
2022 68.7 61.3
2023 69.2 61.8
2024 69.3 62
2025 69.4 62.2
2026 69.6 62.3

Botswana and Sierra Leone population clocks and comparison

Population
Botswana

Sierra Leone
Year Population
Botswana Sierra Leone
1960 516,165 2,268,356
1961 527,942 2,304,227
1962 540,186 2,342,242
1963 552,966 2,382,258
1964 566,266 2,424,390
1965 574,664 2,468,666
1966 577,866 2,514,638
1967 580,933 2,562,384
1968 583,966 2,611,532
1969 587,066 2,661,365
1970 590,334 2,712,286
1971 600,481 2,763,222
1972 622,407 2,814,388
1973 652,408 2,866,955
1974 685,448 2,920,459
1975 720,380 2,974,657
1976 758,508 3,028,820
1977 799,574 3,085,354
1978 849,239 3,145,517
1979 901,742 3,207,499
1980 937,485 3,272,089
1981 969,996 3,338,940
1982 1,009,269 3,408,183
1983 1,046,137 3,481,646
1984 1,083,660 3,558,758
1985 1,121,945 3,638,438
1986 1,160,650 3,728,380
1987 1,199,167 3,829,718
1988 1,235,476 3,934,517
1989 1,270,274 4,034,037
1990 1,305,696 4,196,828
1991 1,341,756 4,246,267
1992 1,380,033 4,166,366
1993 1,420,115 4,157,130
1994 1,460,023 4,173,105
1995 1,498,836 4,179,179
1996 1,535,914 4,199,210
1997 1,571,691 4,253,716
1998 1,606,899 4,295,785
1999 1,641,997 4,318,043
2000 1,677,382 4,423,611
2001 1,712,254 4,692,716
2002 1,744,763 4,971,435
2003 1,775,736 5,177,687
2004 1,807,146 5,355,717
2005 1,839,877 5,501,712
2006 1,874,516 5,624,466
2007 1,911,201 5,749,352
2008 1,949,970 5,894,722
2009 1,990,673 6,055,646
2010 2,033,111 6,222,714
2011 2,073,535 6,387,251
2012 2,108,617 6,551,080
2013 2,140,682 6,714,051
2014 2,172,044 6,876,385
2015 2,203,273 7,037,655
2016 2,234,776 7,205,328
2017 2,266,747 7,379,299
2018 2,299,141 7,554,563
2019 2,332,083 7,731,991
2020 2,365,894 7,912,558
2021 2,401,441 8,094,602
2022 2,439,892 8,276,807
2023 2,480,244 8,460,512
2024 2,521,139 8,642,022

Fertility rates in Botswana and Sierra Leone

Fertility rate
Botswana

Sierra Leone
Year Fertility rate
Botswana Sierra Leone
1960 6.6 6.18
1961 6.56 6.21
1962 6.54 6.22
1963 6.58 6.26
1964 6.61 6.29
1965 6.6 6.31
1966 6.61 6.35
1967 6.6 6.38
1968 6.58 6.39
1969 6.56 6.39
1970 6.55 6.41
1971 6.54 6.43
1972 6.56 6.45
1973 6.59 6.47
1974 6.61 6.53
1975 6.61 6.55
1976 6.6 6.55
1977 6.54 6.57
1978 6.48 6.59
1979 6.4 6.58
1980 6.29 6.56
1981 6.16 6.55
1982 5.97 6.56
1983 5.79 6.57
1984 5.63 6.59
1985 5.48 6.59
1986 5.33 6.6
1987 5.1 6.61
1988 4.88 6.59
1989 4.67 6.57
1990 4.51 6.57
1991 4.37 6.55
1992 4.26 6.56
1993 4.15 6.57
1994 4.02 6.56
1995 3.79 6.56
1996 3.57 6.55
1997 3.43 6.53
1998 3.36 6.5
1999 3.31 6.42
2000 3.29 6.36
2001 3.25 6.31
2002 3.18 6.23
2003 3.11 6.09
2004 3.06 5.92
2005 3.08 5.81
2006 3.11 5.74
2007 3.13 5.64
2008 3.13 5.56
2009 3.13 5.45
2010 3.14 5.33
2011 3.1 5.21
2012 3.07 5.06
2013 3.05 4.87
2014 3.03 4.7
2015 3.01 4.55
2016 2.99 4.47
2017 2.97 4.39
2018 2.94 4.29
2019 2.91 4.19
2020 2.86 4.08
2021 2.83 3.98
2022 2.79 3.88
2023 2.73 3.79

Botswana and Sierra Leone demographics compared

Median age
Botswana

Sierra Leone
Year Median age, years
Botswana Sierra Leone
1960 17.7 21.1
1961 17.4 21.1
1962 17.1 21.1
1963 16.8 21
1964 16.6 21
1965 16.4 20.9
1966 16.2 20.9
1967 15.9 20.8
1968 15.7 20.7
1969 15.6 20.6
1970 15.4 20.4
1971 15.3 20.2
1972 15.4 20.1
1973 15.6 19.9
1974 15.8 19.8
1975 16 19.6
1976 16.2 19.5
1977 16.4 19.4
1978 16.6 19.3
1979 16.9 19.2
1980 16.8 19.1
1981 16.8 19.1
1982 16.8 19
1983 16.8 18.9
1984 16.8 18.9
1985 16.8 18.8
1986 16.9 18.7
1987 16.9 18.7
1988 17 18.6
1989 17.1 18.6
1990 17.3 18.5
1991 17.4 18.5
1992 17.6 18.4
1993 17.8 18.4
1994 18 18.3
1995 18.3 18.2
1996 18.6 18.2
1997 18.8 18.1
1998 19.1 18.1
1999 19.4 18
2000 19.7 18
2001 20 18
2002 20.3 17.9
2003 20.6 17.9
2004 20.9 17.9
2005 21.2 18
2006 21.5 18
2007 21.7 18
2008 22 18.1
2009 22.2 18.1
2010 22.5 18.2
2011 22.7 18.3
2012 22.8 18.4
2013 22.7 18.5
2014 22.7 18.6
2015 22.7 18.7
2016 22.7 18.9
2017 22.8 19.1
2018 22.9 19.2
2019 23.1 19.4
2020 23.3 19.6
2021 23.4 19.8
2022 23.6 20
2023 23.9 20.3
2024 24.2 20.5

Interactive Maps

Use the buttons below to switch between world maps comparing statistics for Botswana and Sierra Leone.

GDP per capita

GDP

Life expectancy

Population

Population density

Fertility rate

Median age

Land area

National statistics comparison

Finance

Botswana Sierra Leone
GNI, Atlas method
$19.5B
2024
$7.08B
2024
Government expenditure, % of GDP
33.4%
2026
15.4%
2026
Education expenditure, % of GDP
8.06%
2020
2.62%
2023
Military expenditure, % of GDP
2.83%
2024
0.46%
2024
Armed forces personnel
9,000
2020
9,000
2020
Deficit/surplus, % of GDP
-9.47%
2026
-2.02%
2026
Unemployment rate
24.4%
2024
3.19%
2018
Services, % of GDP
63.5%
2024
42.6%
2024
Industry, % of GDP
29.4%
2024
25.6%
2024
Economic freedom index
69.9
2025
48
2025
Income share by richest 10%
42.9%
2015
29.4%
2018
Income share by poorest 10%
1.4%
2015
3.4%
2018
Listed domestic companies
23
2023
n/a
Market capitalization of domestic companies
$3.59B
2023
n/a
Total reserves including gold
$3.46B
2024
$433M
2024
Personal remittances received
$128M
2024
$322M
2024
International tourist arrivals
1,830,000
2018
71,000
2019
International tourism as share of exports
4.56%
2020
5.49%
2018
Banked people share
61.4%
2024
38.6%
2024

Energy

Botswana Sierra Leone
Energy use, kg of oil equivalent per capita
1,165 kg
2022
n/a
GDP PPP per kg equivalent of energy use
$17.1
2022
n/a
Carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions
6.9 megatons
2024
1.46 megatons
2024
CO2 emissions per capita
2.74 tons
2024
0.17 tons
2024
Fossil fuel energy use share
0%
2022
n/a
Renewable energy use share
27.4%
2021
71.6%
2022
Alternative and nuclear energy use share
0.08%
2022
n/a
Net energy imports use share
23.7%
2022
n/a
Electric power consumption per capita
1,522 kWh
2022
n/a
Renewable electricity output share
0.25%
2021
75.3%
2021
Hydroelectric share
0%
2021
70.5%
2021
Nuclear share
0%
2021
0%
2021
Electricity access
76%
2023
35.5%
2023

Society

Botswana Sierra Leone
% of world population
0.03%
2024
0.11%
2024
Annual migration change
-5,778
2024
-11,000
2024
Urban population
67.5%
2024
45.4%
2024
Male:Female ratio
50:50
2024
50:50
2024
Average male height
5.68 ft
2025
5.46 ft
2025
Average female height
5.32 ft
2025
5.16 ft
2025
Quality of life index
48.5
2026
30.5
2026
Corruption Perceptions Index
57
2024
33
2024
Higher education index
55
2026
16
2026
Homicides per 100K people
10.5
2021
2.14
2020
Road traffic mortality per 100K people
26.4
2019
33
2019
Visa free countries
86
2025
68
2025
Adult literacy rate
86.8%
2013
48.6%
2022
English speaking
38.4%
2023
83.5%
2023
People using the Internet
81.4%
2023
20.6%
2023

Health

Botswana Sierra Leone
Government health expenditure per capita
$478
2022
$39.3
2022
Out-of-pocket health expenditure per capita
$21
2022
$20.7
2022
Life expectancy
69.6 years
2026
62.3 years
2026
Foreign aid share of health expenditure
6.34%
2022
28%
2022
Physicians per 1,000 people
0.38
2022
0.04
2022
Age at first childbirth
19 years
2017
19.6 years
2025
Maternal mortality per 100K births
155
2023
354
2023
Mortality rate before reaching 5 years of age, per 1,000 live births
39.6
2023
94.3
2023
Obesity rate
18.6%
2022
7.32%
2022
Diabetes prevalence
4.6%
2024
4.8%
2024
Air quality index
39
2026
16
2026
Tobacco use prevalence
18.7%
2022
12.9%
2022
Pure alcohol consumption per capita
7.27 liters
2020
0.29 liters
2020

Territory

Botswana Sierra Leone
% of world land
0.38%
2026
0.05%
2026
Land area per capita
86,792 sq mi
2024
3,225 sq mi
2024
Agricultural land area
99,854 sq mi
2026
15,247 sq mi
2026
Forest area
57,528 sq mi
2026
9,559 sq mi
2026
Roads length
19,727 mi
2017
7,270 mi
2015

In-depth comparisons

Facts comparisons

Facts vs Botswana vs Sierra Leone
Afghanistan Compare Compare
Albania Compare Compare
Algeria Compare Compare
Andorra Compare Compare
Angola Compare Compare
Antigua Compare Compare
Argentina Compare Compare
Armenia Compare Compare
Australia Compare Compare
Austria Compare Compare
Azerbaijan Compare Compare
Bahamas Compare Compare
Bahrain Compare Compare
Bangladesh Compare Compare
Barbados Compare Compare
Belarus Compare Compare
Belgium Compare Compare
Belize Compare Compare
Benin Compare Compare
Bhutan Compare Compare
Bolivia Compare Compare
Bosnia Compare Compare
Brazil Compare Compare
Brunei Compare Compare
Bulgaria Compare Compare
Burkina Faso Compare Compare
Burundi Compare Compare
Cambodia Compare Compare
Cameroon Compare Compare
Canada Compare Compare
Cape Verde Compare Compare
Cayman Islands Compare Compare
CAR Compare Compare
Chad Compare Compare
Chile Compare Compare
China Compare Compare
Colombia Compare Compare
Comoros Compare Compare
Congo Compare Compare
Costa Rica Compare Compare
Croatia Compare Compare
Cuba Compare Compare
Curacao Compare Compare
Cyprus Compare Compare
Czech Republic Compare Compare
DR Congo Compare Compare
Denmark Compare Compare
Djibouti Compare Compare
Dominica Compare Compare
Dominican Republic Compare Compare
East Timor Compare Compare
Ecuador Compare Compare
Egypt Compare Compare
El Salvador Compare Compare
Equatorial Guinea Compare Compare
Eritrea Compare Compare
Estonia Compare Compare
Eswatini Compare Compare
Ethiopia Compare Compare
Fiji Compare Compare
Finland Compare Compare
France Compare Compare
Gabon Compare Compare
Gambia Compare Compare
Georgia Compare Compare
Germany Compare Compare
Ghana Compare Compare
Greece Compare Compare
Grenada Compare Compare
Guatemala Compare Compare
Guinea Compare Compare
Guinea-Bissau Compare Compare
Guyana Compare Compare
Haiti Compare Compare
Honduras Compare Compare
Hungary Compare Compare
Iceland Compare Compare
India Compare Compare
Indonesia Compare Compare
Iran Compare Compare
Iraq Compare Compare
Ireland Compare Compare
Israel Compare Compare
Italy Compare Compare
Ivory Coast Compare Compare
Jamaica Compare Compare
Japan Compare Compare
Jordan Compare Compare
Kazakhstan Compare Compare
Kenya Compare Compare
Kiribati Compare Compare
Kuwait Compare Compare
Kyrgyzstan Compare Compare
Laos Compare Compare
Latvia Compare Compare
Lebanon Compare Compare
Lesotho Compare Compare
Liberia Compare Compare
Libya Compare Compare
Liechtenstein Compare Compare
Lithuania Compare Compare
Luxembourg Compare Compare
Madagascar Compare Compare
Malawi Compare Compare
Malaysia Compare Compare
Maldives Compare Compare
Mali Compare Compare
Malta Compare Compare
Marshall Islands Compare Compare
Mauritania Compare Compare
Mauritius Compare Compare
Mexico Compare Compare
Moldova Compare Compare
Monaco Compare Compare
Mongolia Compare Compare
Montenegro Compare Compare
Morocco Compare Compare
Mozambique Compare Compare
Myanmar Compare Compare
Namibia Compare Compare
Nauru Compare Compare
Nepal Compare Compare
Netherlands Compare Compare
New Zealand Compare Compare
Nicaragua Compare Compare
Niger Compare Compare
Nigeria Compare Compare
North Korea Compare Compare
North Macedonia Compare Compare
Norway Compare Compare
Oman Compare Compare
Pakistan Compare Compare
Palau Compare Compare
Palestine Compare Compare
Panama Compare Compare
Papua New Guinea Compare Compare
Paraguay Compare Compare
Peru Compare Compare
Philippines Compare Compare
Poland Compare Compare
Portugal Compare Compare
Qatar Compare Compare
Romania Compare Compare
Russia Compare Compare
Rwanda Compare Compare
Saint Kitts Compare Compare
Saint Lucia Compare Compare
Saint Vincent Compare Compare
Samoa Compare Compare
San Marino Compare Compare
Sao Tome Compare Compare
Saudi Arabia Compare Compare
Senegal Compare Compare
Serbia Compare Compare
Seychelles Compare Compare
Singapore Compare Compare
Slovakia Compare Compare
Slovenia Compare Compare
Solomon Islands Compare Compare
Somalia Compare Compare
South Africa Compare Compare
South Korea Compare Compare
South Sudan Compare Compare
Spain Compare Compare
Sri Lanka Compare Compare
Sudan Compare Compare
Suriname Compare Compare
Sweden Compare Compare
Switzerland Compare Compare
Syria Compare Compare
Taiwan Compare Compare
Tajikistan Compare Compare
Tanzania Compare Compare
Thailand Compare Compare
Togo Compare Compare
Tonga Compare Compare
Trinidad Compare Compare
Tunisia Compare Compare
Turkey Compare Compare
Turkmenistan Compare Compare
Tuvalu Compare Compare
Uganda Compare Compare
Ukraine Compare Compare
UAE Compare Compare
United Kingdom Compare Compare
United States Compare Compare
Uruguay Compare Compare
Uzbekistan Compare Compare
Vanuatu Compare Compare
Vatican Compare Compare
Venezuela Compare Compare
Vietnam Compare Compare
Yemen Compare Compare
Zambia Compare Compare
Zimbabwe Compare Compare